Cheryl Ann Hindsley
March 15, 1947 ~ May 13, 2026
Born in:
El Reno, Oklahoma
Resided in:
Pueblo, Colorado
Cheryl A. Hindsley departed this life on Wednesday May 13th in Pueblo, Colorado. Cheryl was born in El Reno, Oklahoma, and started her life as a military brat, traveling the world with her parents. She graduated from high school in Tokyo Japan, and then later attended the University of Oklahoma, earning her teaching degree. While in college, she made many trips to Colorado to ski and fell in love with the natural beauty of Colorado. After graduation, Cheryl moved to Pueblo Colorado and began her professional career teaching science and swimming at South High School. She later met Betty Williams, who convinced Cheryl to become a realtor. Thus, beginning a long and successful career in real estate. Cheryl was named Salesperson of the Year in 1989, Realtor of the Year in 2003, and received a Lifetime Achievement Award in 2010.
Throughout her fifty plus years of being a real estate professional, Cheryl involved herself in many community committees including Pueblo Leadership, Colorado State Fair Parade Committee chair, Junior Livestock Committee at the Colorado State Fair, and multiple real estate committees and boards. She was especially proud of the many young realtors that she mentored over the years. She championed Pueblo like no other, and loved to take visitors to the Sangre de Cristo Art Center, the Pueblo Reservoir and Riverwalk, the Raptor Center, and was a great ambassador for all things Southern Colorado.
Although real estate was her love, her absolute passion was animals. She was an early supporter of Paws for Life, and dedicated her energy, passion, and skills to help Paws for Life become a special part of Pueblo as a no-kill shelter. Cheryl dedicated her free time helping with fundraising, the annual golf tournament, the plant sales, and spent countless weekends introducing shelter animals to the public for adoption. Cheryl was instrumental in helping to raise necessary capital investment for the expansion of Paws infrastructure. Cheryl proudly served as a legacy board member for many years, and her leadership will be sorely missed. In her lifetime, Cheryl owned many rescue horses, birds, and countless dogs that she provided with incredible love and devotion.
Cheryl is survived by her son, Jerry Mize (Shelly) of Arkansas; grandson, Garrett (Leah) Mize of Texas; granddaughter, Brailey (Matdey) Mize of Arkansas; great-grandchildren, Emory and Breck of Texas, fur babies, Ginger, Riley, and Max, and countless other friends and wagging tails in Pueblo, Southern Colorado, and around the country.
Cheryl was preceded in death by her parents, Colonel John A. Hindsley, and Georgann Hindsley.
In lieu of flowers, donations may be made to Paws for Life in Cheryl’s name. Per Cheryl’s request, there will not be a memorial service. Online condolences, www.MontgomerySteward.com
View current weather.
Memories Timeline
Photo Gallery
Donna and I were introduced to Cheryl by my mother when they worked at the South High pool. After setting up our first home purchase, Cheryl became our go to realtor. More importantly she became a life long friend. Cheryl will be remembered and loved for time eternal.
I got to know Cheryl through Fair Ladies and 4H. She was a great supporter of kids and animals. Always positive with a smile on her face. A neat lady, who will be dearly missed.
Cheryl was our realtor for several years as we searched for our forever home in Pueblo. When it became clear that we definitely had to move, Cheryl spent an entire weekend with us searching for our home. Once we found it and made our plans to move, Cheryl went above and beyond to make sure everything was ready for us I still have the house warming gift she gave us, Our friendship continued for many years as we would have lunch or dinner together. We had not seen her in a few years, and we are both saddened that Cheryl is gone. We are blessed to have had Cheryl in our lives
My first year as a real estate broker in 1984 at Van Schaack, I met Cheryl. I had a great time with the entire crew under Betty Williams. What fun, Cheryl was the best!
Thank you to everyone for the condolences. The family really enjoys the personal experiences you shared with Mom. We read every one and would love to hear more, if you have them.
The Brake Family
Rick, Jill, Lacey, Drew, Taylor
Sending my condolences to Cheryl’s family and to her MANY friends. She was truly an amazing woman. Rest in Peace.
Cheryl ,
This one hurts. I am glad you’re not on pain and you’re free to run the fields with the animals. We had so much fun being each other’s plus 1 for weddings and Funerals. When I eat fried pickles I will smile and think of you. Rest easy.
Many people can say that about other people,but in this case..it’s SPOT ON.
I hadn’t seen Cheryl in awhile.
She was without a doubt the busiest person,I think I ever new,
And she liked it that way.
She will be missed by many and absolutely her fur babies.
May your journey be peaceful,and restful.You my friend have earned it.
Miss you already.
💔💔💔
Bet Allen